Discussion

(2 comments)
  • 1
    Profile picture
    Tech Lead @ Robinhood, Meta, Course Hero
    2 months ago

    For folks who aren't aware, the original Devin demo was proven to be faked: Devin's Demo As The "First AI Software Engineer" Was Faked

    I use AI tools regularly. As a YC founder, I have also interacted with lots of AI startups led by brilliant founders (ex-Google/Meta Staff+ MLEs). While AI is already proving to be tremendously useful, I haven't seen much evidence that it can be a relatively independent, autonomous, highly-functional entity on an engineering team. We actually tinkered with an AI tool that would automatically generate pull requests for simple bugs/features, and it failed miserably. Again, this was a tool built by very high-quality AI founders, not randoms.

    In short, I'm not giving much attention to the Devin until I see more results. I'm sure it's a lot jankier than the founders realize.

    • 1
      Profile picture
      Junior SWE [OP]
      Taro Community
      2 months ago

      yeah for sure. I linked a blog where they say that it's able to solve PRs in open source repos. they say that it really shines in doing grunt work that no one wants to do